2024 Cadillac XT4 Pros vs Cons, & Competitor Insights

If you're eyeing a posh and peppy little luxury SUV, the newly refreshed 2024 Cadillac XT4 deserves your attention. This nimble crossover brings plenty to love, from its punchy turbo engine to an elegantly appointed cabin. But it's not all sunshine and smooth rides - loud engine noise and overzealous driver aids require overlooking. We'll dissect the pros and cons of Cadillac's compact entrant and see how it stacks up to established competitors like the Volvo XC40 and BMW X1. Ideal for shoppers considering a small but mighty luxury SUV packed with comfort and technology, read on to see if the XT4 should be on your shopping list.

What We Like: The Top Ten Pros

The Cadillac XT4 hits a sweet spot for compact luxury SUVs. This stylish Caddy is fun to drive with peppy acceleration and nimble handling. The head-turning exterior doesn't hurt! With advantages from performance to practicality, the XT4 makes a strong case to love this SUV. Let's dive into the top ten reasons this fun-sized Cadillac stands out.

1. Smooth and Responsive Power Delivery

When you hit the gas in the XT4, it feels eager to go - the acceleration is responsive and refined. The powertrain and chassis work together nicely to make driving feel agile and energetic.

• The turbocharger gives the 2.0L engine a boost, so it feels more powerful when accelerating or merging onto the highway. You get a nice punch of acceleration.

• Send power to the front wheels or all four with the all-wheel drive system. The AWD gives you extra traction and control on slippery roads when accelerating.

The nine-speed automatic transmission is really helpful in a few ways:

• With so many gears, it can always find the perfect one for smooth, efficient power delivery at any speed.

• Shifts between gears are super smooth and prompt. No harsh shifts or hesitation.

• Keeps the engine "in the zone" at its ideal rpm as conditions change.

Some other features that contribute to great acceleration:

• Adaptive dampers tune the ride for agile handling when driving dynamically.

• The available sport suspension takes it up a notch for even sharper handling.

Lastly, tech like Active Fuel Management lets the engine cruise efficiently when you don't need full power. But it's ready to deliver energetic acceleration when you step on it.

Overall, the well-matched powertrain and chassis give the XT4 an eager and responsive feel. Driving this SUV is a smooth and enjoyable experience.

2. Nimble Handling Characteristics

The XT4 delivers a pretty smooth, comfy ride while still handling nimbly for an SUV. It strikes a nice blend:

• Passengers enjoy the smooth ride quality that absorbs bumps decently well. The SUV glides over most road imperfections.

• In turns, the XT4 exhibits little body lean and stays stable. The steering feels precise too, going where you point it.

• It resists body roll thanks to the sporty yet compliant suspension tuning. Some reviewers found the ride overly firm, but we think Cadillac found the sweet spot.

• The compact XT4 is very maneuverable, making it easy to zip into tight parking spaces thanks to its nimble handling.

Overall, the ride and handling provide an agile yet family-friendly driving experience.

3. Good Smart System Suite of Safety and Driver Assistance Features

The XT4 has Cadillac Smart System, packing a comprehensive suite of standard driver assistance and safety features. This advanced tech aims to provide peace of mind by helping you avoid collisions and stay in control. Available on the base Luxury model (base price starting at $39,090) on up you have the following features:

• Blind Zone Steering Assist - Helps prevent collisions when changing lanes.

• Rear Cross Traffic Braking - Applies automatic emergency braking if it detects cross traffic when backing up.

• Pedestrian Braking - Brakes if it detects a pedestrian in front of your vehicle.

• Following Distance Indicator - Displays how many seconds you are behind the car in front of you.

• IntelliBeam High Beams - Automatically switches between high and low beams based on presence of other vehicles.

• Lane Keep Assist - Uses steering input to keep you centered in your lane if drifting is detected.

• Safety Alert Seat - Unique haptic vibration in the driver's seat as an added collision warning. (Can be switched to audible alerts if desired)

Available on the the upper trim models, Premium Luxury ($42,690) and the XT4 Sport model ($43,190) feature the Active Safety Package:

• Adaptive Cruise Control - Automatically maintains a set following distance behind detected vehicles.

• Intersection Braking - Provides automatic emergency braking if it detects a potential collision when entering intersections.

• HD Surround Vision - Gives a 360 degree view around your XT4 on the screen when parking or maneuvering at low speeds.

• Reverse Automatic Braking and Rear Pedestrian and Side Bicyclist Alert also come with this package.

With an array of available driver-assistance features, Cadillac's Smart System provides an extra layer of protection and confidence through advanced aids that help avoid accidents and collisions.

The NHTSA gave the XT4 a safety rating of 5 out of 5 stars. (Source: NHTSA) The IIHS Safety Rating is not available yet.

4. Infotainment and Connectivity

The XT4 comes loaded with user-friendly infotainment and connectivity features to keep you entertained and connected on the go.

At the center is a large is a Google built-in infotainment experience with a 33-inch-diagonal Advanced Color LED Display offering crisp graphics and GM's latest software. Here are some of the handy standard features:

• Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto support to mirror your smartphone apps

• Google Built-In and Amazon Alexa integration

• Built-in apps like Google Play, Spotify, Audible books, and Alexa voice assistant

• Hands-free calling and media functions to stay focused on driving

• Available embedded navigation system with pinch-to-zoom maps

• Optional premium AKG surround sound system with 14 speakers

You'll never run out of USB ports for hooking up devices. A 5G WiFi hotspot offers great wireless connectivity - it lets passengers tap into high-speed data when away from home.

Voice controls via Siri or Google make the XT4's infotainment a breeze to use. Over-the-air software updates help keep things current. Overall, you'll be entertained and connected in the XT4.

5. Eye catching Exterior Styling

The XT4 turns heads with its eye-catching new look. Up front, the fascia sports vertical lights and fresh headlamps flanking Cadillac's signature grille.

• Sleek integrated headlamps boost curb appeal. Premium Luxury and Sport trims get custom grilles too.

• New 18- and 20-inch wheel designs plus vibrant colors like Emerald Lake Metallic help you personalize.

• Bigger than subcompact rivals, the XT4 has commanding road presence and ample interior space.

Overall, elegant and bold styling combines for a modern, striking appearance. The XT4 showcases Cadillac's audacious signature style in a compact luxury SUV package.

6. Roomy, Comfortable Cabin

For a small SUV, the XT4 pampers passengers in its well-appointed cabin. Available amenities like heated/ventilated front seats, leather upholstery, and ambient interior lighting further enhance the upscale ambiance. Generous space lets adults fit comfortably in back. Rear passengers enjoy best-in-class rear leg room.

Up front, supportive power adjustable seats make it easy to find the perfect position. The available Cold Weather package adds features like heated front and rear seats and steering wheel provide luxury.

The higher ground clearance enables easy entry/exit access. The ride height gives a satisfying view outward for front seat occupants. Thoughtful touches include rear window shades, abundant storage and adjustable steering column.

With its premium materials, ample room and cozy amenities, the XT4 delivers an upscale yet welcoming environment. It's designed to keep all passengers happy during rides.

7. Luxuriously Appointed Cabin with Quality Materials

Inside you'll find a meticulously constructed interior that punches above its weight class. Let's look at some of the details that give this little Caddy a big dose of luxury:

• Plush leather & suede - Available leather seating features intricate perforation patterns and accent stitching. Higher trims add suede accents like the headliner for a premium vibe.

• Real wood & metal trims - Accent the dash and doors with your choice of wood, carbon fiber or metal trims, allowing you to customize the look.

• Padded & stitched dash - Runs your hand along the dash and you'll find a soft-touch padded surface with elegant stitching for a quality feel.

• Quiet-zone cockpit - Intensive sound insulation creates a peaceful sanctuary from noise. You'll appreciate the hushed highway rides.

• Small luxury touches - The little details add up, like ambient cabin lighting, metallic pedals and abundance of padding throughout.

While it may be the smallest SUV Cadillac makes, they didn't skimp on crafting a truly upscale interior environment. The XT4 brings a taste of luxury in a fun-sized package.

8. The XT4's Spacious & Luxe Cargo Hold

The cargo area has nearly 50 cubic feet of space - enough room for around 17 grocery bags when the rear seats fold. The carpeted floor keeps your goods looking nice. This little SUV still packs a capacious cargo hold and clever storage that caters to your daily needs:

• Smart storage abounds between the large console, abundant door pockets, cargo tray and seat back compartments.

• One-handed access lets you quickly retract the cover when you need to open up more room.

• Several tie-down hooks allow you to securely fasten items.

The XT4 proves you can have both indulgent leather and ample utility. It pairs a flashy cabin with spacious, convenient cargo capability.

9. Good Towing Capacity for the Class

While not intended for heavy towing, the XT4 can manage moderate loads when equipped with the available trailering package. This package boosts the maximum towing capacity to 3,500 pounds.

By integrating a trailer hitch receiver, enhanced cooling capability, and select mechanical upgrades, the trailering package enables the XT4 to tow small camping trailers, boats, or cargo trailers with ease.

For a compact SUV, the XT4's tow rating competes well against rivals like the BMW X1 and Volvo XC40. While best suited for light recreational towing, the XT4 provides an unexpected level of capability.

10. Good Warranty Coverage and Quality Rating

The Cadillac XT4 stands out with its longer 6 year/70,000 mile powertrain warranty compared to 4 years/50,000 miles for the Audi Q3, BMW X1 and Volvo XC40. The Mercedes-Benz GLA has a Drivetrain Warranty of 5 years/60,000 miles. The bumper-to-bumper warranty for all five vehicles is 4 years/50,000.

This should alleviate some fears about powertrain quality some reviewers mention as a con. The truth is that JD Power gave the XT4 a Quality & Reliability of Great with a score of 85/100. The reliability rating gives you an idea of how problem-free a vehicle will be. It tallies up all the defects, malfunctions, and flaws that pop up across the entire vehicle. 85/100 beats the Audi Q3 (81/100), BMW X1 (72/100 ), Volvo XC40 (72/100) and the Mercedes-Benz GLA (79/100). (Source: J.D. Power)

What We Don't Like - Four Cons

While the 2024 Cadillac XT4 shines in many respects, it does have some limitations to weigh. Here are four cons identified from professional evaluations of the vehicle.

1. Loud Engine Noise

The turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine powering the XT4 emits noticeably loud and unrefined noise, especially during hard acceleration. The engine almost seems to struggle, producing a raspy and metallic din not expected from a luxury vehicle. This can detract from the otherwise hushed and elegant interior ambiance.

While adequate in terms of power delivery, the four-cylinder simply lacks the refinement and smoothness characteristic of luxury brands. Some reviewers thought the noisy nature of accelerating diminished the premium driving experience promised by the XT4. This engine rattle and roar is a disappointing drawback.

2. Controls Take Some Acclimation

The XT4 has a sharp looking and responsive touchscreen interface. However, some vehicle controls like the buttons and knobs on the center console require an initial learning curve. The buttons are numerous and their functions not immediately intuitive.

The electronic gear selector in particular takes time to get comfortable with, say reviewers. There are also multiple control knobs with close secondary knobs that make it tricky to find the right one by feel. While owners eventually adapt, the XT4's controls lack the simplistic elegance expected of a luxury vehicle.

3. Just Okay Acceleration and Fuel Economy

The XT4's powertrain performance and fuel efficiency are merely adequate rather than exceptional. The turbo four-cylinder provides sufficient but not abundant power. In Motor Trend testing, the XT4 took an unimpressive 7.3 seconds to reach 0 to 60 mph - slower than key rivals. Fuel economy is comparable to competitors at 22 mpg city and 29 highway, but no segment leader. (Source: Motor Trend, EPA)

While the XT4 offers acceptable acceleration and efficiency, it does not particularly excel in either criterion. Shoppers desiring brisk performance or excellent fuel economy may be disappointed. The XT4 instead focuses more on comfort and features over raw performance stats.

4. Lane Departure Warning/Lane Keeping Assistance Fell Flat

According to ConsumerReports.org, the XT4's Lane Departure Warning and Lane Keeping Assistance systems fell a bit flat in testing. Here's a quick rundown:

• The audible warnings activate frequently, even when you haven't left your lane. This gets annoying and leads drivers to shut the systems off.

• The steering assist from Lane Keeping Assistance is barely noticeable. It doesn't add any meaningful steering help.

• Using the systems on winding backroads actually makes driving harder, with constant unwanted warnings. They work best on straight highways.

• The systems only work above 37 mph, limiting their usefulness around town.

While the intent is good, the execution misses the mark. The excessive warnings become more of a nuisance than an asset. Cadillac still has some work to do to refine these driver aids and make them truly helpful on the road. (Source: ConsumerReports.org)

5. Strengths and Weaknesses vs the XT4's Competition

The XT4 faces some stiff competition in the small luxury SUV playground. Let's pit the XT4 against similar vehicles such as the Q3, X1 and XC40 to see where it wins and loses. A few key differences emerge that buyers will need to prioritize. Read on to see how Caddy fares against the Germans and Swedes.

Vs. Audi Q3:

• The XT4 excels with nimbler handling, smoother ride, and extra cargo space. Its turbo engine accelerates faster too.

• But the Q3 counters with a more premium cabin, better tech, and standard Quattro AWD. The Audi also undercuts the XT4 on starting price.

Vs. BMW X1:

• The Cadillac wins on power, ride quality, cargo room and standard safety tech. Its infotainment is easier to use as well.

• However, the X1 takes handling, interior luxury, rear seat space and AWD capability. Plus eye-catching looks.

Vs. Volvo XC40:

1. More muscle, suspension comfort and interior room give points to the XT4. As do standard safety features across trims.

2. But the Volvo gains ground with its superior tech, stylish interior, efficiency, AWD and head-turning design.

So in summary, the XT4 shows strengths in power, ride and space while rivals like the Q3, X1 and XC40 emphasize design, luxury and AWD. Shoppers will have to prioritize if the XT4 or the other car will sit in their driveway.

Summing it Up

With its upscale design inside and out, enjoyable driving dynamics, and generous suite of infotainment features, the 2024 Cadillac XT4 makes a compelling case in the small luxury SUV segment. Ideal for shoppers wanting a more youthful yet sophisticated compact crossover, the XT4 artfully blends technology, luxury, and utility.

While performance and fuel economy are just average, and some controls counter-intuitive, the XT4 impresses as an aspirational and relatively affordable luxury vehicle. Between its stand-out styling, cabins space, and generous equipment even at base level, Cadillac has delivered a well-rounded premium package with the updated 2024 XT4. It deserves a test drive by anyone shopping compact SUVs in this price range.